Reaper (CW) -- To be honest, there was only one real reason to watch this show, and his name is Ray Wise. Sure, the show was about Sam (Bret Harrison), a young man forced to collect escaped souls for the devil, but as Lucifer, Wise was so deliciously evil that we were actively rooting for him to kick Sam's butt. The show didn't quite fit in with the CW's lineup, however, and the network decided it wasn't worth bringing back for a third season. On the bright side, the show ended with the devil totally claiming the upper hand over Sam.